Skip to content
JUS·DOSSIER

Justice, courts and the legal profession

What the courts actually decided, as distinct from what was reported. Judgments, procedure, and the condition of the profession itself.

The thread, oldest first
  1. JUS·2007·0015 June 2007
    P.G. looses civil injuction against Aruba.

    On June 5th, 2007 The Courts of Aruba declared a civil claim of the prosecutor general "PG" inadmissible. The PG demanded that her pension to be adjusted i

  2. JUS·2007·00713 juni 2007
    Disclaimer Afkondiging Blad Aruba AB 2007 no. XVII

    Hoewel bij de totstandkoming van deze landsverordening de uiterste zorg is nagestreefd door de wetgever, kan voor de afwezigheid van eventuele drukfouten e

  3. JUS·2008·0168 July 2008
    Dutch American Friendship Treaty recognized by the Aruba Courts

    In a recent decision Extreme Sports/Kunder vs Ministry of Immigration the administrative court of Aruba “LAR” has declared local immigration statute non-bi

  4. JUS·2012·08723 October 2012
    The EU Court of Justice has confirmed its previous ruling that passengers whose flights have been delayed for a long time may be compensate

    Where passengers reach their final destination three hours or more after the scheduled arrival time, they may claim fixed compensation from the airline, un

  5. AVI·2013·0953 June 2013
    DAE-aircraft briefly arrested in Suriname

    DAE-aircraft briefly arrested in Suriname. The aircraft was released and returned to Curacao with no passengers. According to the media Suriname Airways is

  6. JUS·2014·11611 December 2014
    Aruba first in the Dutch Caribbean to get appeal in tax matters in two instances as of January 2015

    As of January 2015 Aruba tax subjects will have the possibility to appeal at the Court in First instance and the Court of Appeals in tax matters. This purs

  7. LAB·2017·1331 March 2017
  8. JUS·2023·14915 augustus 2023
    Medisch dossier op Aruba: van een inzagerecht naar een informatieplicht?

    Medisch dossier op Aruba: van een inzagerecht naar een informatieplicht? Laatst sprak ik een arts die meende dat, anders bv dan in Colombia, een patiënt di

  9. JUS·2023·153September 3, 2023
    Pone e ser keri bou di curatela. Con esey ta bai?

    Un biaha na trabou m’a haya un yamada di un conoci di mi tata. Despues di a saluda el a puntra si por a dun’e un man pa kita e firma di su casa. El a pone

  10. JUS·2023·15413 september 2023
    Inheritance Tax Cases in Aruba - abolished (again!!)

    In a recent development, we have received confirmation that the Aruban tax authorities have chosen not to file an appeal with the Supreme Court in an impor

  11. JUS·2023·1598 October 2023
    Child Kidnapping 2023: Are We Doing Enough to Protect Our Youngest?

    Today’s column encapsulates the urgency of our times and the moral imperative to protect our most vulnerable citizens, our children. This week I take a clo

  12. COR·2023·1608 oktober 2023
    Kinderontvoering anno 2023: Doen we genoeg om onze kinderen te beschermen?

    In deze column wil ik onze juridische en morele morele plicht om onze meest kwetsbare burgers, onze kinderen, te beschermen, centraal stellen. Deze week be

  13. JUS·2023·1618 de octubre de 2023
    Secuestro de niños en 2023: ¿Estamos haciendo suficiente para proteger a nuestros más jóvenes?

    La columna de hoy encapsula la urgencia de nuestros tiempos y el imperativo jurídico y moral de proteger a nuestros ciudadanos más vulnerables, nuestros ni

  14. JUS·2023·17210 November 2023
    Equality is off to the Supreme Court

    Originally published on March 6th, 2023

  15. JUS·2023·17312 November 2023
    Supreme Court Hearing on Same-Sex Marriage in Aruba and Curaçao: What Happened and What Lies Ahead?

    In a much-anticipated and historic event, on Friday, November 10th, 2023, the Supreme Court Hoge Raad Der Nederlanden held

  16. JUS·2023·1784 December 2023
    UNION PROTESTER SENTENCED FOR TRESPASSING

    n a 2022 Supreme Court case, the defense argued on behalf of the accused, who had been co

  17. JUS·2024·18710 January 2024
    Understanding Civil Proceedings in Aruba

    The legal system in Aruba and the Netherlands is known for its efficiency and fairness, but these processes can sometimes be complex and time-consuming. It

  18. JUS·2024·18810 January 2024
    What is the Civl Court Docket or Civiel Rol?

    1. Definition: The civiel rol is essentially a schedule or list of civil cases that a court is set to hear. It organizes and outlines the cases that the co

  19. JUS·2024·19211 February 2024
    26 Years: Upholding the Integrity of Our Judicial System

    This week it will be twenty-six 26 years since this kid walked into the Court of First Instance of Aruba building. There was a special hearing of what was

  20. JUS·2024·19429 February 2024
    Arrest of  Aircraft in Aruba and Curaçao

    Whether you are the owner of an aircraft on lease, a lender, or a vendor that has provided goods or services to an aircraft owner, there comes a time when

  21. JUS·2024·1951 de marzo de 2024
    Embargo de Aeronaves en Aruba y Curacao - 2024

    Ya sea que seas el propietario de una aeronave en arrendamiento, un prestamista o un proveedor que ha proporcionado bienes o servicios a un propietario de

  22. JUS·2024·1964 March 2024
    Planes and claims

    Image: IG @alvcro What a week it has been in my aviation practice. Lots of stuff going on, including two aircraft grounded for regulatory reasons in differ

  23. AVI·2024·19925 March 2024
    WARNING: THIS IS NOT A COLUMN!!

    We all know the feeling when you wake up one day and dread one or more thing s. Whether it is “leg day” at the gym, you’re still sore from your last run or

  24. JUS·2024·20215 April 2024
  25. JUS·2024·2218 September 2024
    SVB’s Discriminatory Practices: Another Victory for Equality

    The recent Torrealba Gonzalez vs. Sociale Verzekeringsbank SVB

  26. JUS·2024·2288 oktober 2024
    Minister Glenbert Croes Arrested in Portulaca Investigation: Unusual Detention Raises Concerns

    In a significant development today, October 8, 2024, Minister of Labor, Energy, and Integration Glenbert Croes was arrested as part of the ongoing Portulac

  27. JUS·2024·23322 October 2024
    The Power of Empathy in the Court of First Instance of Aruba

    This week, I appeared in the Court of First Instance of Aruba for a divorce case. It was quite different from my usual work in corporate law and finance, b

  28. JUS·2024·23718 November 2024
    Moving Forward: A Simpler Path to New Beginnings

    In 2024, the number of marriages in Aruba hovered just over 400, while the number of divorces was slightly under 400—a statistic that underscores how close

  29. JUS·2025·25124 februari 2025
    Een ode aan “onze” Sigrid Torres – een vrouw achter Justitie

    Sommige mensen werken voor Justitie. Anderen zijn Justitie. Sigrid Torres behoort zonder twijfel tot die laatste categorie. Ze heeft misschien nooit een to

  30. JUS·2025·2584 April 2025
    When Trees Cross the Line: What Every Homeowner and Realtor Should Know

    A recent appellate court ruling in Aruba has drawn a firm legal boundary - literally - on one of the most common neighborhood issues: trees planted too clo

  31. JUS·2025·2597 April 2025
    Sevinger’s Shadow Grows: What the Court’s Money Trail Reveals

    Earlier, I wrote about the corruption case against Benny “Avestruz” Sevinger, comparing it to the Dutch trial of Richard de Mos. That piece focused on lega

  32. JUS·2025·26730 May 2025
    A Snapshot Of: De Meza vs. the Tax Department

    Earlier this week, I attended the court hearing in the case between candidate minister Mike de Meza and the Tax Department. Before it began, I was asking m

  33. GOV·2025·2694 June 2025
    The De Meza Ruling: Legal & Constitutional Boundaries 

    The recent ruling in De Meza v. Director of Taxation AUA202501405 & AUA202501407

  34. JUS·2025·2718 June 2025
    Bad Water, Big Trouble: Court Tells Golf Course to Stop Spraying Stench

    In a ruling that doesn’t just clarify the law but sends a bree

  35. GOV·2025·27216 June 2025
    When Power Gets Comfortable: The People vs Guillfred Besaril

    Case : P-2024/00395 In public service, the boundary between personal comfort and public duty should be crystal clear. But as we’ve seen repeatedly in Aruba

  36. JUS·2025·2746 July 2025
    The Plastic Test of Power

    It is rare for two court rulings, issued within weeks of each other, to tell the same story from opposite ends of the legal spectrum. One is civil. The oth

  37. JUS·2025·28428 September 2025
    The Aruba Bar Association, looking back and looking forward.

    From its humble beginnings in 1991 to the challenges of today, the Aruba Bar Association continues to evolve with Aruba. When we talk about institutions th

  38. JUS·2025·28619 October 2025
    Fault Lines, Part 2: What the Courts Keep Telling Realtors

    The last column struck a chord. It was shared widely, picked up by media outlets, and sparked conversations in coffee shops and boardrooms. But what stood

  39. JUS·2025·28915 December 2025
    The Ghost Employees of Aruba: When Willing Participation Isn’t Innocent

    In a democracy, public trust is currency. And in small island nations like Aruba, where government institutions are both omnipresent and deeply personal, t

  40. JUS·2025·29121 December 2025
    What the Judge Brings to the Bench

    Not long ago, I wrote about a hearing that reminded me why this profession still matters to me after all these years. It was a case that showed how much di

  41. JUS·2025·29229 December 2025
    Two Aviation Cases. Two Courts. Two Very Different Outcomes.

    It’s rare for aviation-related matters to land in administrative court in our part of the Kingdom - rarer still for it to happen twice, in summary proceedi

  42. LAB·2026·30315 March 2026
    The Young Kid at the Registration Desk

    The story of a great lawyer. Lawyers meet many people during their careers. Clients, colleagues, adversaries, judges. But every now and then, someone walks

  43. JUS·2026·305March 29, 2026
    WTHOFA?

    Tin hopi discusion tocante "HOFA". Hopi opinion. Hopi conclusion. Pero no tur opinion ta basa riba e documento mes. Laga nos ta honesto… Cuanto di nos a le

  44. JUS·2026·3065 April 2026
  45. JUS·2026·30815 april 2026
    The End of the Road: When the Law Falls Silent

    A Brief Ruling, A Final Outcome On April 14, 2026, the Supreme Court of the Netherlands brought the criminal case known as "Averstuz" to a final conclusion

  46. JUS·2026·31725 July 2026
    Justice Doesn't Forget

    Justice is often criticized for moving too slowly. Court cases can take years to investigate, prosecute, and finally conclude. To many, the wheels of justi

  47. SOC·2026·31825 July 2026
    The Dog That Became Mine

    It’s a dog-eat-dog world out there. Perhaps that’s why, while reviewing this week’s court judgments, one case